‘You Have Something to Hide:’ Amplify Energy Absent Again from State Hearing on OC Oil Spill 


Monday kicked off a chain of public autopsies via state lawmakers into the verbal exchange delays and regulatory gaps which allowed an offshore oil spill to smear tar throughout Orange County’s iconic sea coast final month. 

But significantly absent from the primary listening to via the California – read more on Surf Report LA – State Meeting’s Select Committee on the Orange County Oil Spill — which additionally mentioned phasing out offshore drilling — was once the very corporate which owns the pipeline that leaked:

Magnify Power Corp.

“I do wish to categorical my excessive unhappiness in Magnify Power’s refusal to take part in these days’s listening to,” stated State Assemblywoman Cottie Petrie-Norris (D-Laguna Seashore), who represents a big phase of Orange County’s sea coast, from Huntington Seashore to Laguna Seashore.

It’s the second time the corporate has declined to make itself out there for public hearings with state officers, the primary time referring to an Oct. 28 legislative oversight listening to in Sacramento. 

“Their absence these days is the entire extra traumatic,” stated Petrie-Norris originally of the Monday listening to, including that the corporate’s refusal to take part sends “very transparent” messages to the general public:

“A, you don’t care. B, you could have one thing to cover.”

Dan Steward, Vice President of Beta Operations at Magnify Power, in a Nov. 12 letter to the committee defined his corporate’s refusal:  “Given the more than a few ongoing investigations into this incident, we don’t seem to be able to responsibly solution your questions right now.” 

“Within the quick time period, Magnify stays thinking about operating throughout the Unified Command because the reaction continues to wind down, seashores reopen, and coated claims are reviewed and processed,” Steward’s letter provides.


It’s estimated that 25,000 gallons of crude oil spilled final month, a smaller quantity than what was once first of all feared. Alternatively, 82 birds and six mammals have been recovered lifeless over the process cleanup efforts as of Nov. 11.

“We will be able to proceed to toughen the communities suffering from this match and cooperate with regulatory investigations as they continue,” the corporate wrote in its letter.

The state oil spill committee has more than one goals, specifically to spot the place enhancements may also be made in crisis reaction protocols and offshore pipeline law. 

However lawmakers have additionally signaled the committee will discover phasing out offshore oil platforms. 

The thing is for the committee to assemble knowledge from those hearings for conceivable legislative motion, with some other listening to eyed for a while in January, in keeping with Petrie-Norris’ place of business.

State Assemblywoman Cottie Petrie-Norris (D-Laguna Seashore) on the first assembly of the California – read more on Surf Report LA – State Meeting’s Make a selection Committee at the Orange County Oil Spill, on Nov. 15. Credit score: California – read more on Surf Report LA – State Meeting assembly video

On Monday, the panel had two different Orange County state representatives in attendance: 

State Assemblywoman Laurie Davies (R-Laguna Niguel), who represents probably the most southern a part of OC coast; and Assemblywoman Janet Nguyen (R-Huntington Seashore), who represents Seal Seashore and portions of Huntington Seashore. 


Huntington Seashore Mayor Kim Carr, who gave public testimony, once more raised questions over the communication gaps and conflicting knowledge her town won from the U.S. Coast Guard within the early days of the spill. 

The Coast Guard has confronted scrutiny over its prolong in performing on early reviews about oil sightings within the water initially of October. In the meantime, Magnify Power has confronted questions on why it waited hours after a rupture alarm to close down the pipeline.

“Hours make an enormous distinction,” Carr stated, including that “if we had a pair extra hours” then possibly the town can have averted extra harm. 

Huntington Seashore’s sea coast is house to a lot of coastal wetlands, that are key migration issues and habitats for endangered and at-risk species. Oil seeped into the Talbert Marsh. 

To this point, Carr stated the town has spent $500,000 in public cash on cleanup and reaction. Issues would were worse, she added, if her town didn’t occur to have a readily-available provide of cleanup and reaction apparatus which it bought via a grant.

Throughout Monday’s listening to, California – read more on Surf Report LA – Dept. of Fish and Flora and fauna Director Charlton Bonham mirrored on some courses realized in state crisis reaction efforts final month. 

“One of the vital issues that slowed us down this spill is, we spent numerous cycles looking for the following position for the incident command publish,” Bonham stated. “We want to get past that and do our due diligence sooner than a spill, so we all know the best public venues which don’t seem to be operated via the accountable celebration” — one thing which “undercuts accept as true with.”


Enhancements to crisis reaction generation also are so as, Bonham stated — specifically, midnight spill detection.

At night time, he stated, “it’s close to unattainable to determine a dismal sheen at the hours of darkness of night time on a dismal ocean floor — however I gotta suppose, with California – read more on Surf Report LA – being” a pacesetter in generation, “there could be enhancements in that house.”

Assemblywoman Davies raised issues Monday over the committee’s eventual matter of phasing out offshore drilling — specifically over its financial affects and whether or not selection strategies, corresponding to transporting oil via freight, would include their very own dangers. 

Bonham refused to “stake a coverage flag” based on her issues, which got here within the type of a query, however stated, “when we’ve got offshore oil manufacturing we can all the time have the chance of a spill.” 

Based on Davies’ query, Petrie-Norris stated a spill’s financial affects — shutting down the coastal economic system — would turn out a ways worse for his or her constituents. 

Carr recounted the ones affects to her town final month, in her testimony, describing how lodges and eating places suffered immense losses because of the spill coinciding with native occasions just like the Pacific Airshow.

“There was once no method you must recuperate should you bought a ton of meals or provisions for an enormous crowd that simply doesn’t occur,” she stated, including the crisis dealt her town, and the county sea coast general, “a little of recognition harm” from a tourism point of view. 

To not point out the “day-to-day well being affects” of oil manufacturing, and the air pollution it reasons, to other people, stated thirty ninth District State Assemblywoman Luz Rivas (D-San Fernando Valley), who represents portions of Los Angeles County. 

“Each and every time we’ve got made enhancements in oil spill prevention and reaction … oil all the time reveals new techniques to get into the surroundings to the purpose {that a} spill turns out inevitable,” Rivas stated.


Garry Brown, the founding father of the Orange County Coastkeeper environmental advocacy team, informed committee contributors {that a} strategy to the problem hinges on collaboration with the oil manufacturers off California – read more on Surf Report LA – ’s coast

There are 4 offshore oil platforms within the state-controlled waters of California – read more on Surf Report LA – , and 23 oil and gasoline manufacturing amenities situated in federally-controlled waters alongside the state sea coast, according to the State Lands Commission.

The “huge corporations” which constructed the platforms “are long past,” Brown informed the panel, “with way more marginal corporations” working those which stay energetic. 

He added those corporations are “working at a price,” and “​​there are stakeholders prepared to come back to the desk.” At one level, Brown stated he didn’t suppose an offshore drilling ban was once essential: “I feel we will have to check out collaboration first.”

By means of comparability, committee contributors like state Assemblyman Richard Bloom (D-Santa Monica) noticed it this fashion:

“Sadly, oil spills and subsequently those hearings will proceed till we take away all petroleum … from our coast.” 

Six weeks in the past, state Sen. Dave Min (D-Irvine) publicly promised to introduce law doing simply that. 

Debates over offshore drilling “went dormant” in California – read more on Surf Report LA – through the years, Brown stated. “And if there’s been the rest sure about this oil spill, it’s to most likely reignite the dialog.” 

Purchase a Voice of OC blouse, espresso mug or tote bag to turn your toughen locally whilst supporting your nonprofit newsroom. Based on preliminary comments from some readers, we wish to observe that these kind of efforts don’t value Voice of OC the rest to sponsor.


» Start each day informed with our loose and OC-focused e-newsletter.

» Be in the know with Voice of OC’s loose breaking information textual content messages.

Because you’ve made it this a ways,

You’re clearly hooked up for your neighborhood and price just right journalism. As an impartial and native nonprofit, our information is offered to all, without reference to what they may be able to find the money for. Our newsroom facilities on Orange County’s civic and cultural lifestyles, now not ad-driven clickbait. Our newshounds grasp tough pursuits responsible to give protection to your high quality of lifestyles. But it surely’s now not loose to supply. It will depend on donors such as you.